The Best Alternatives to Weight Watchers

For decades, Weight Watchers has been the standard-bearer for the weight loss industry, helping countless people live better, healthier lives. The company's model is based on “Smart Points” which allow you to eat and drink anything you like as long as you don't surpass your daily points limit. Really healthy food like vegetables typically has zero points, while the more sinful stuff will cost you some points.

You can receive your points allowance either through a meeting with a Weight Watchers representative or on the company website after you become a Weight Watchers members. You can also earn extra points for exercise, encouraging you to work out but also creating an interesting and helpful incentive for exercise.

Weight Watchers works wonders for a lot of people, but if you’d like to entertain some other options, here 5 of the most appealing alternatives to Weight Watchers.

Top 5 Alternatives to Weight Watchers Diet


1. NutriSystem

Pros

  • Eat 6 meals a day

  • Suitable for diabetics, vegetarians and other dietary restrictions

  • 150+ menu options

  • Money back if you don’t lose weight in the first 14 days

Cons

  • Much of the food comes frozen

  • Orders take a few days to arrive

A diet doesn’t need to be all about depriving yourself, and with NutriSystem you can still enjoy many of the foods you love - in moderation.

With NutriSystem you are encouraged to eat small portions often - as many as 6 meals a day. There is a whole team of nutritionists working to design the meal plans, and if you don’t lose weight in the first 14 days you can ask for your money back.

NutriSystem also comes with a handy mobile app that integrates with a number of health apps such as Fitbit, Apple Health, Jawbone and more.

With the premium plans, you can choose between a favorites pack and a custom menu. There are more than 150 menut items offered, and while it takes 4-10 business days for the food to arrive, the variety means you’ll always have a lot of options.

Like Weight Watchers, the point of NutriSystem isn’t to get you to stop eating, but to manage what you eat with smarter portions of healthier food.

  Basic Plan Core Plan Uniquely Yours
 Price per day $9.96 $10.68 $12.29
 Shipping Cost Free Free Free

 

View Plan


2. Mayo Clinic

Pros

  • Focuses on your long-term health

  • Daily diet tips and meal tracker

  • Affordable

  • 24/7 customer support

  • Includes healthy carbs

Cons

  • No food delivery option

  • No in-person support

For years the Mayo Clinic has been one of the world’s most prestigious medical research institutions, and now you can put the clinic’s world-class know-how to work for you in your weight loss plans.

With the Mayo Clinic Diet, you single out your bad food habits and adjust your diet accordingly, while also working in a solid amount of physical activity. Every member gets a personalized diet plan as well as advice, customer support, and customized exercise plans, for the price of only $5/week.

Unlike Weight Watchers, the system isn’t based solely on food and there is no points system to determine what you eat. Instead, it’s based on portions and tracking your servings. It also combines with your workout regimen to determine how many calories you can take in.

The Mayo Clinic diet doesn’t cut out all carbs or sugars, and allows you to take in a healthy amount. This is not a crash diet, it’s a plan to help you out in the long term, largely through targeting the bad eating and lifestyle habits that hold you back.

 Membership price 
 Weekly $5/week

 

View Plan


3. South Beach Diet

Pros

  • For heart-conscious dieters (designed by a cardiologist)

  • 3 meals per day and snacks available

  • Weight loss consultants available

Cons

  • Must cut gluten, sugars, and starches

  • You need room to store 4 weeks worth of frozen food

  • Menu options fairly limited

The South Beach Diet has long been more than a fad diet, and is here to stay. With the South Beach Diet plan, you enter into a 3-phase plan that is devoted to your long-term weight loss and health.

You sign up for a 4-week meal plan which you can customize. Most of the food will come flash frozen, and then you need to start arranging the coming days accordingly, with 3 meals a day included. In the first phase you cut out gluten, sugars, and starches and start losing weight. Slowly start moving healthy carbs back into your diet and when you reach your goal weight you receive a number of simple recipes to help you keep the weight off.

The plan is designed by a cardiologist with heart health in mind. Unlike Weight Watchers, it isn’t based on a point system in which you can just eat anything you want as long as you don't exceed your points. Instead, there are relatively strict limits on the type of foods that are allowed.

 Price Snacks Shipping Packaging
 $461.52 $40 Free $1.99

 

View Plan


4. BistroMD

Pros

  • Dieticians help you create a custom diet

  • Expansive menu - more than 150 meals to choose from

  • Can also cover gluten free, diabetic, menopause, and other specialized diets

Cons

  • No a la carte single meal options

  • No full vegetarian or vegan plans available

Ever think how nice it’d be to have your own dietician figuring out what you should eat, and then going out and doing the shopping and cooking for you? With BistroMD that’s how it works. Registered dieticians create a custom diet based on your unique needs and then you pick the meals for your diet.

The options are quite expansive and very flexible, including for gluten-free, low-carb, and people with special food allergies or aversions. You pick between a full 5-day or 7-day program or a 7-day or 5-day lunch and dinner program.

From there it’s a sort of “teach a man to fish” concept. The idea is for you to take what you’ve learned from your time with BistroMD to create healthy, delicious meals of your own as part of a new, healthier approach to life.

In a sense it’s a much more comprehensive option than Weight Watchers. You don’t merely get a point system and a regimen to stick to, you get the meals delivered straight to your door ready to go. It costs far more than Weight Watchers, but that’s for you to decide if it's worth it.

 Full program  Full program Lunch & dinner  Lunch & dinner 

 7 days

  5 days

 7 days

 5 days

 $134.96 $112.46 $112.46 $89.96

 

View Plan


5. GreenBlender

Pros

  • Delicious smoothies for less than $4/serving

  • You get everything you need in the deliveries including fruit/veg and superfoods

  • All ingredients organic and non-GMO

  • Get enough ingredients to make 10 smoothies a week

Cons

  • It’s only smoothies - you better like smoothies

  • Less customer service options than other diet plans

Sometimes nothing is better than a tall, cold smoothie first thing in the morning.

GreenBlender has cornered some of the weight loss market through marketing a plan that sends you all the daily ingredients you need for as many as 10 great smoothie per week. All of the ingredients are organic and non-GMO, with some powerful superfood ingredients. Blender is not included though.

Unlike Weight Watchers, you don’t get a customized day-by-day comprehensive meal plan to help you plan your overall diet. On the other hand, you do get actual fresh ingredients shipped to your house to help you start your day right.

1 week of ingredients1 month of ingredients3 months of ingredients
 $49/week $176 per month $468
 $4.90 per serving $4.40 per serving $3.90 per serving

View Plan


Bottom Line

Weight Watchers is without a doubt the most well-known weight loss plan provider and the company was a groundbreaker in the industry. That said, today there are more options than ever for people who are looking for ways to lose weight or at least just learn methods to eat and live healthier. These companies use mobile apps to maximize the user experience in ways that were all but unthinkable when Weight Watchers first opened in the 60s.

If you’re looking for a way to lose weight or just eat better, take a look at what your needs are and how much you can budget, and then try some of these new weight loss plans, which provide more options than ever before.

Check out our comparison of the leading weight loss plans for more information.

Advertising Disclosure

This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the rating that is assigned to them. To the extent that ratings appear on this site, such rating is determined by our subjective opinion and based on a methodology that aggregates our analysis of brand market share and reputation, each brand's conversion rates, compensation paid to us and general consumer interest. Company listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information, including pricing, which appears on this site is subject to change at any time.

GOT IT

*The information on this site is based on research, but should not be treated as medical advice. Before beginning any new diet plan, we recommend consulting with a physician or other professional healthcare provider. Results may vary based on various health factors, individual weight loss plans and adherence to the meal plan.